Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This page may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that I have recommended. There is no additional cost to you whatsoever.
Is Ivanpah shutting down due to an underhanded deal earlier than Biden left workplace?
A little-known $15 billion deal between PG&E and the Department of Energy is elevating considerations for California residents. The settlement, which can increase hydropower, additionally contains shutting down the Ivanpah photo voltaic plant, which has been offering power to 140,000 properties.
Without this dependable supply of fresh power, California’s already overburdened energy grid will battle, resulting in larger power prices and extra frequent blackouts. Critics argue that whereas PG&E advantages financially, on a regular basis Californians will probably be left paying the value with elevated payments and an excellent much less dependable energy system.
Questions are additionally being raised about doable conflicts of curiosity with key gamers within the deal, making it much more controversial. We spoke with one of many important traders of the $2.2 billion Ivanpah plant to be taught extra.
___
In the ultimate days of the Biden administration, a serious power deal quietly unfolded that would have long-lasting penalties for California’s energy grid and taxpayers. A $15 billion mortgage assure from the Department of Energy (DOE) to Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) for hydropower growth has raised considerations about power reliability, price, and who in the end pays the value. This deal, which has been largely unreported, means that the Biden administration orchestrated a backroom settlement that advantages PG&E whereas undermining California’s already fragile grid.
The coronary heart of the difficulty lies in PG&E’s settlement to buy out Ivanpah’s power purchase agreement (PPA), which can end result within the shutdown of the Ivanpah photo voltaic plant, a serious renewable power facility. With Ivanpah’s closure, the 140,000 properties it powers should depend on the already overburdened grid, particularly throughout peak demand hours. This will additional pressure the grid at occasions when power consumption is highest, resulting in extra frequent blackouts and an excellent much less dependable energy system for California.
Related: what we can learn from Ivanpah’s failure
What’s extra regarding is that the power PG&E will lose from Ivanpah, which may be one of the inexpensive sources of energy throughout peak demand, will must be changed by power bought from the market. However, PG&E’s market purchases are anticipated to come back at a considerably larger price. These elevated prices are more likely to be handed on to ratepayers, in the end negating any supposed financial savings from the deal and doubtlessly inflicting long-term charge will increase for California shoppers. The choice to close down Ivanpah not solely jeopardizes power reliability but in addition threatens to undermine the state’s clear power transition.
Ivanpah photo voltaic power panels
A greater different would have been for the DOE to restructure Ivanpah’s mortgage, permitting the ability to stay operational whereas investing in power storage applied sciences to assist meet peak demand. “Ivanpah produces energy for 140,000 properties, and has been a dependable supply of power for California residents for over a decade,” stated Neal Lee, Vice President of CMB, one of many lead traders within the Ivanpah challenge to Green Prophet.
Related: Why the Collapse of a $2.2 Billion Solar Dream Threatens the Future of Renewable Energy
“We applaud the Trump Administration’s efforts to unleash the total energy of American power, and rectify the unhealthy offers the earlier administration struck that may take power off the grid. We stay up for working with Secretary Wright to assist implement his all-of-the-above power technique, and are excited to proceed our work with the Department to search out extra methods to supply inexpensive, dependable power throughout high-demand hours.
“Continued innovation on this plant will increase its capability and its lifespan, and guarantee it powers properties in a state that wants it lengthy into the longer term,” he added.
Adding to the complexity of this story is the latest hiring of former Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm to the board of Southern California Edison (SCE), which receives power from the Ivanpah plant, says an undisclosed supply near the deal.
“We’re thrilled she is becoming a member of our boards, and we stay up for the steering she’s going to present primarily based on her understanding of the technical, political and financial forces shaping our business at this time.” stated Pedro J. Pizarro, president and CEO of Edison International, in an announcement.
This transfer raises questions on doable conflicts of curiosity, given Granholm’s involvement in shaping power coverage throughout her tenure as Secretary, alludes an advisor working with Lee. “Her new function with SCE has prompted considerations that her affect might have performed a job in orchestrating offers just like the one between PG&E and the DOE, doubtlessly prioritizing the pursuits of personal power firms over these of California’s residents,” the supply says.
At the center of this difficulty is the truth that, whereas PG&E stands to learn from the mortgage assure and the Ivanpah deal, it’s California’s taxpayers and residents who’re left to bear the prices. The shutdown of Ivanpah will weaken the state’s power infrastructure, may enhance the probability of blackouts, and should in the end elevate electrical energy costs. PG&E is below no obligation to switch Ivanpah’s power at an economical charge, which means ratepayers are more likely to really feel the monetary pressure for years to come back. The deal seems to be a short-term achieve for PG&E, however on the expense of long-term power reliability and affordability for California residents, says our supply.
__
CMB holds the fairness place in Solar Partners that was initially owned by BrightSource (now Kelvin Energy). Solar Partners is a bigger group that features NRG, Google, and Kelvin, all of which personal and function the Ivanpah energy plant. CMB can be one of many main traders in Kelvin Energy, which holds a 13% stake in Solar Partners. In brief, CMB is concerned each in proudly owning a part of the Ivanpah energy plant by Solar Partners and as a serious investor in Kelvin Energy.
