The Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Recycling

The Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Recycling

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This page may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that I have recommended. There is no additional cost to you whatsoever.

Despite our greatest intentions, all the pieces we do has some environmental influence. Even although true sustainability could also be out of attain, environmentalism is about making trade-offs to attenuate the hurt that comes from our actions. Since our world is made up of complicated methods, it isn’t all the time simple to determine which decisions have the most effective environmental outcomes. Sometimes, alternative that appears extra clearly sustainable isn’t really the greenest or doesn’t make as a lot distinction as you’d anticipate. Take, for instance, one latest examine of the greenhouse fuel emissions created by recycling.


Recycling was one of many first environmental decisions to go mainstream. There are a lot of things you are able to do which have a much bigger influence in your carbon footprint. But to at the present time, recycling remains to be the very first thing most individuals consider when they consider saving the planet.

A variety of components go into designing a municipal curbside recycling system – issues like worker safety, ease of participation for residents, methods for minimizing contamination, what sort of processing services can be found and the way a lot they value to function, market demand for the recyclables and for the recycled supplies they may produce. And relying on these components, communities can select from a number of completely different recycling methods.

In the start, all recycling was supply separated. That means each materials required its personal bin, and even completely different colours of glass needed to be separated. In the Nineties, the appearance of materials recovery facilities (MRFs) enabled commingled, or single-stream, recycling the place all the pieces was collected in a single bin. What contains “all the pieces” varies amongst communities and should exclude plastics and/or glass. More lately, many communities have begun composting organic waste, which necessitates a separate bin for the gathering of meals and yard waste.

Trash, recycling, and compost bins
Many communities now supply composting providers along with single-stream recycling.

Life Cycle Analysis of Recycling Systems

Because recycling is broadly assumed to be a common good, few individuals have regarded carefully on the environmental impacts it produces. But a latest life cycle analysis by the Environmental Research & Education Foundation (EREF) in contrast greenhouse fuel emissions and fossil gas power use amongst landfilling, recycling, and composting to search out out whether or not utilizing a recycled materials is all the time higher than utilizing a virgin materials. And the answer was extra sophisticated than you may anticipate.

For the examine, EREF checked out 4 eventualities:

  • All-landfill (one bin)
  • Curbside single-stream recycling (two bins: rubbish and recycling)
  • Curbside single-stream and yard waste composting (three bins: rubbish, recycling, yard waste)
  • Curbside single-stream and mixed yard/meals waste composting (three bins: rubbish, recycling, organics)

Unsurprisingly, recycling does emit fewer greenhouse gases than landfilling. But the distinction wasn’t all the time very important.

  • A easy two-bin, single-stream system had the most effective outcomes with a 38% discount in emissions in comparison with landfilling all the pieces.
  • A 3-bin system combining meals and yard waste solely decreased emissions by 10%.
  • Emissions from three-bin methods that solely settle for yard waste had been roughly equal to the landfill.

The examine attributed the effectivity loss for three-bin methods to extra fossil fuels used for curbside assortment of a 3rd bin. Managing the compost piles (particularly for pile aeration) additionally added to the emissions of three-bin methods. Presumably, mixed meals and yard waste outperformed yard waste-only methods as a result of meals waste contributes so much to landfill emissions whereas it improves the nutrient stability in a compost pile. The addition of meals waste may contribute to efficiencies of scale of economic composting methods.

Man putting plastic bottle into recycling bin
Make positive the native recycling guidelines and put solely supplies your service accepts into your recycling bin.

What Should You Do?

Regardless of how your curbside recycling system is structured, it’s nonetheless a good suggestion to take part. In most circumstances, you may be saving no less than some greenhouse fuel emissions. Even with out lowering greenhouse fuel emissions, all eventualities resulted in power financial savings in comparison with simply landfilling. They additionally famous the numerous environmental advantages of composting that their evaluation doesn’t seize.

But you may attempt to recycle higher. MRFs that course of the supplies should discard contaminated recyclables — an extra step that lowers the general effectivity of the operation. Make positive you perceive which supplies your native recycling service accepts. Avoid “wishcycling” and take away non-recyclable lids and labels from containers earlier than you set your recyclable objects within the recycle bin.

You can even talk together with your native utility and elected officers to advocate for a greener system. Inform them of the outcomes of this examine. And allow them to know that the gap from assortment to processing can cut back the environmental advantage of their program. According to the examine, plastics and metals will be transported 1000’s of miles with out negating the emissions advantages of recycling them. But transporting glass 1,150 miles and transporting fiber (paper and cardboard) 360 miles negates their emissions financial savings from recycling. Investing in the green economy by establishing processing services nearer to the supply can shield the surroundings and create native jobs.